Botox as Treatment for Major Depressive Disorder
Feb 28, 2022 09:31AM ● By Alithia MonroeWhen Botox exploded as a cultural phenomenon in the 90s as a
wrinkle smoother, other—and arguably greater—medical Botox uses were also being
discovered. Some of the lesser known are Botox treatment for chronic migraines
and bladder incontinence, spastic bowel, dystonia, autonomic disorders, chronic pain and certain types of eye disorders. Now, extensive research shows Botox
helps people with major depressive disorder feel better.
Botox
is a neurotoxin derived from the bacterium Clostridium botulinum. Ingested
in contaminated food, it can cause paralysis, or even death, but when injected
in tiny doses, it causes hyperactive muscles to relax by blocking signals
between nerves and muscles. In the 1970s, Dr. Alan B. Scott, an
ophthalmologist, was studying the toxin as a therapy for people with strabismus
(crossed-eyed) when he noticed an incidental finding of eye wrinkle smoothing.
Fast forward and today, Botox is in the toolbox of many medical specialties.
In 2014, Dr. Norman Rosenthal, clinical
professor of psychiatry at Georgetown University School of Medicine who first
described seasonal affective disorder, published a double-blind randomized study. In this study of 74 subjects diagnosed with major depressive disorder, the results showed that
Botox injected into two eyebrow frown muscles (the corrugator and procerus
muscles) subjects showed a 50 percent or greater reduction in depression rating scale
scores six weeks following the injection. Many more Botox studies have been
published in peer reviews dating back to 2006 with positive outcomes for
depressed patients treated with Botox.
How Botox works for depression
The
answer may date back to the 19th century when Charles Darwin described what was
subsequently called the “omega sign” of melancholy, today’s equivalent of the
cosmetic “11’s lines” heard on Botox television commercials. The
Darwin-described grief muscles contract when crying and they maintain
micro-tension even when the depressed person doesn’t appear to be frowning.
When Botox is injected into these two grief muscles, they lose their ability to
contract reliably and predictably within two weeks of treatment.
The significance of this was first
proposed by Charles Darwin and elaborated by William James in the facial
feedback theory that suggests that an individual’s experience of emotion is
influenced by feedback from their facial movements. That is, the outward
expression of an emotion intensifies it. By extension, therapeutic Botox that
weakens frown muscles creates a “fake it until you make it” scenario.
Nina Bull, an underappreciated figure in the history of body psychotherapy, was a pioneer in the mind-body relationship, emphasizing the role of the musculature in subjective experience. She explains, “Preparation for an action precedes, not follows, the subjective awareness of emotion.” In other words, when a depressed person’s frown makes ready for emotional sadness, the body keeps the score.
Another reason for Botox’s anti-depressive
effects is rooted in social feedback theory since the world responds more
positively to a happier face than a sad face. With Botox-weakened frown
muscles, the feedback loop is rendered more positive. It is possible that after
Botox treatments, people feel less sad because the people around them respond
more positively to them.
Botox has been sensationalized as a cosmetic intervention for the
youth obsessed while its significant medical uses remain largely unknown in the
lay population. Tillman Kruger, a psychiatrist at Hannover Medical School who
did a metanalysis of Botox for depression, explains, “When the brain recognizes
something emotional happening in the body, the emotion behind it gets
enriched.” Blocking frowning with Botox breaks that feedback loop.
Alithia Monroe is a trained physician assistant and has experience as a co-investigator at Brigham and Women’s Hospital and Dermatology clinical experience since 2005.
She is mission-driven to help people along their healing path, with nearly two
decades of experience injecting Botox to improve facial expressions and
facilitate more positive feedback and a better mood. Connect at AskBeautyTherapist.com.